Why (Not) the Buick Enclave?
Buyers' reasons for buying--or not buying--a particular car
View reviews for a different model
Direct link to this page
TrueDelta's "Why (Not) This Car?" reviews of the Buick Enclave, posted by owners, focus on the information most sought by many car buyers: the reasons to buy (or not buy) the Buick Enclave compared to other car models.
Not a member yet? Read about TrueDelta's research and how to participate by clicking here.
- Car buyer comparisons: Buick Enclave preferred
- Car buyer comparisons: Buick Enclave not preferred
- Single vehicle reviews: Buick Enclave pros and cons
Comparisons: Buick Enclave Preferred
2010 Buick Enclave4-door SUV | > | 2007 Honda Ridgeline4-door SUT |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Ride smoothness: Very smooth, even over rough roads |
Quietness: Very quiet and don't have to increase volume on radio at hwy speeds. No wind noise unless a very strong side wind and then only minimal. |
Reliability & durability: Have owned two Enclaves now and no major problem in 46,000 miles total. |
Exterior styling: Large vehicle that doesn't look that large. Aerodynamic styling smooth flowing lines Nothing else quite so elegant on the road in this size. Nice optional wheels so don't have to buy aftermarket |
Interior styling: Nice dash layout. Like the color of wood grain trim Like color options |
| Top of page ^ |
| Honda Ridgeline: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Ride smoothness: Don't dislike the ride smoothness. Rather this is a strength. |
Quietness: Again this is a strength as is very quiet on the interior. |
Reliability & durability: ONly problem I've had in 62,000 miles is the intermitant airbag light comes on. |
Driving position & visibility: C pillar blind spot. Otherwise, I really like the driving position. |
Rear seat room & comfort: Nothing and is a strength. My golfing buddies love to ride with me. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV | > | 2009 Honda Pilot4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Materials & workmanship: for the money the nicest looking and richest interior in the field. |
Quietness: In a vehicle with so much going on the quietness is commendable. Little outside noise intrudes into the passenger compartment. |
Exterior styling: One of if not the best looking crossover vehicles out there today |
Powertrain performance: smooth and quiet with reasonable fuel mileage |
Ride smoothness: smooth ride with confidant handling |
| Top of page ^ |
| Honda Pilot: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: clunky looking, more trucklike |
Quietness: fine around town, Awful on the highway. It vibrates and the passenger cabin is loud. I think this vehicle needs more developement in the NVH area. Hondas noise cancelling technology doesn't impress me. |
Control design: Too many buttons on the center stack with a confusing layout. |
Powertrain performance: Not very smooth. Works hard at 70-75 MPH, fuel mileage suffers at interstste speeds |
Dealership practices: Two trips to dearlership for the same problem, still not fixed. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV | > | 2004 Pontiac Bonneville4-door Sedan |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Cargo capacity & towing: Ample room with 3rd row folded. |
Brand reputation & image: Buicks, and GM, are known to be reliable. |
Quietness: Blocks out most common road noise and vibration. |
Exterior styling: Elegant, beautiful, smooth, stylish, unique, bold, timeless, American. |
Powertrain performance: Fast, responsive, smooth, fun to drive. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Pontiac Bonneville: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Cargo capacity & towing: Not enough room for a family of 4 to travel on a trip. |
Rear seat room & comfort: Entry and exit a little difficult, not much room with a child car seat installed. |
Front seat comfort: Passenger seat not comfortable on long trips, without the optional power seat. |
Handling: Pulls to the right. Has, since new. |
Powertrain performance: Has a little hesitation when during full throttle starts. |
| Top of page ^ |
2008 Buick Enclave4-door SUV | > | 2008 Toyota Sienna4-door Minivan, ext. |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Smooth, flowing lines. Not straight and boxy like most vans. |
Interior styling: Luxurious and spacious. Well-appointed. |
Quietness: Very quiet...isolates road and wind noise very well. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Toyota Sienna: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Body panels are too straight - no character. |
| Top of page ^ |
2008 Buick Enclave4-door SUV | > | 2008 Mercedes-Benz GL-Class4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Enclave had all the features of the Mercedes, for $20M less with better overall fuel economy. |
Fuel economy: Honest 23 mpg on the freeway. |
Ride smoothness: Smooths out bumps but handles well. |
Quietness: Quieter than the Mercedes. Quietest vehicle on the road. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Mercedes-Benz GL-Class: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Fuel economy: Even the diesel isn't that great in town and it now cost $4/gal. |
| Top of page ^ |
Comparisons: Buick Enclave Not Preferred
2010 Ford Flex4-door SUV | > | 2011 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Ford Flex: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Color choices: I fell in love with Cinnimon Metallic. I believe they have a strong line of color choices available. |
Available features: It would be easier telling you what I don't like then it would to tell you about what I like. Basically... bumper to bumper - it is easy to fall in love with the Flex. |
Price or payments: I feel that this is a decent vehcile for the cost. |
Exterior styling: The Flex is a unique vehicle in it's styling escaping from the cookie-cutter styles that are commonly seen today. |
Fuel economy: I am currently averaging 20 MPG overall with heavy highway use. For the size of vehicle I think that is rather reasonable. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Price or payments: The price seemed a bit high, however, this is a top notch vehicle. |
Exterior styling: The exterior seemed cookie-cutter to me. Don't get me wrong, the attention to detail was there, however, the same basic styling is used on many other models. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Nissan Murano4-door SUV | > | 2008 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Nissan Murano: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: everything |
Interior styling: Everything |
Handling: Peppy drive train |
Reliability & durability: first nisson,but son has altima and no problems yet.( 3 yrs old) |
Materials & workmanship: everything |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Reliability & durability: G.M. reputation |
Price or payments: 5 - 7 thousand more then murano |
Fuel economy: Fuel economy is good for suv this size.( As big as Tahoe ) |
Brand reputation & image: G.M. has problems with all vehicles |
Materials & workmanship: Cost- to exspenive for same or better in murano |
| Top of page ^ |
2008 Honda Odyssey4-door Minivan, ext. | > | 2008 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Honda Odyssey: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Cargo capacity & towing: Lot's of room for stuff behind the third row, larger usable space interior with seats down/out. |
Available features: The Touring model is loaded with darn near anything I'd want in a vehicle. The Voice Nav, bluetooth, power doors, memory seating, all were well implemented. It's an Acura of Minivans. |
Materials & workmanship: Very nice interior, well placed controls, good fit and finish. Small details done well throughout. |
Reliability & durability: Based on friend's experiences and Honda in general, is a dependable vehicle. |
Rear seat room & comfort: I'm going to be having a family of SEVEN soon, and needed the most space with ease of entry and cargo behind the third row. The Odyssey wins this contest hand's down. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Reliability & durability: My past GM experience hasn't been all that good. Reading long-term ownership experiences in common blogs identify some major mechanical problems I wouldn't expect in a new vehicle. |
Price or payments: Price was higher than the van, mostly I believe due to higher demand for crossovers than vans. |
Fuel economy: It's lower, but not drastically out of character. The tranny seems to be a weak point, providing adequate mileage for sub-par performance. |
Insurance & depreciation: Don't know of any GM vehicle that does well in depreciation. Insurance costs also higher. |
| Top of page ^ |
Single Vehicle Reviews: Buick Enclave Pros and Cons
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Cargo capacity & towing: I love the way the hitch receiver is out of sight until needed, and the hidden rear compartment is a great place to stow the hitch. As much cargo space as much larger SUV and you can really get 7 people in this vehicle. |
Available features: It has every feature you could want. |
Exterior styling: Great lines, everything looks like it belongs, lines connect well from all angles, nothing out of place. |
Interior styling: Classy, nothing tacky, great lines, well postioned controls. |
Discounts & incentives: Great time to buy, buyers market. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Looks better than other Lambda's |
Quietness: With Quiet Tuning it is very Quiet |
Ride smoothness: Rides smoother than other CUV's |
Rear seat room & comfort: More room than competing CUV's |
Available features: Like options available |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Price or payments: Higher than most |
Insurance & depreciation: Depreciation higher because of GM status |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Cargo capacity & towing: With seats folded flat there is not too much you cannot load in the vehicle. With seats up, comfortable seating for 7 real-sized adults. Well thought out. |
Exterior styling: Smooth attractive aerodynamic shape suggesting power and sophistication. Definitely does not resemble older "stodgy" Buick styling yet gives a sense of quality. |
Powertrain performance: Rapid response of the Direct Injection engine without the "buzzy feel" of most large V-6 engines and the weird vibration their 120 degree timing gives the driver. |
Fuel economy: More than reasonable for a 5000 lb vehicle. Benefits of aero design ( for an SUV ) and six speed transmission both contribute. |
Ride smoothness: Independent Rear Suspension makes it ride like a car not a truck. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Powertrain performance: Smooth acceleration, plenty of reserve power |
Cargo capacity & towing: Minivan-comparable without the stigma |
Quietness: Easily THE quietest care I've ever owned |
Ride smoothness: Luxurious |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Fuel economy: Well under (15-20%) below the EPA ratings, though the engine is STILL brand new (<400 miles total). |
Insurance & depreciation: More expensive to insure than I'd hoped |
Price or payments: I'd like EVERY car to be priced lower than it is |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Buick Enclave4-door SUV |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Available features: OnStar Standard HID Headlights Standard memory seats, mirrors & steering Standard Heated Front Seats Standard Power Liftgate Standard Bluetooth Hands-free Available Steerable Headlights Available Heated & Cooled Seats Interior Layout, Stor |
Ride smoothness: Very comfortable and smooth for drivers and passengers. Feel this is the best in this class. |
Quietness: Very quiet ride. Again, feel this is the best in the class. |
Cargo capacity & towing: Very roomy, ample cargo room. All this with equal or better fuel economy compared to competition. |
Price or payments: Feature to feature you can't beat the Enclave in terms of price/value ratio especiallywith incentives. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Buick Enclave: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Driving position & visibility: Poor visibility from rear window. The small cleaning area of rear window wiper makes it even worse. A negative for winter weather in Northern climes. |
Audio & nav systems: The audio reproduction from Bose system is poor, lacks crispness and bass. Highly overrated system; feel it should be a lot better for a vehicle of this class. The Nav system is sometimes inaccurate, clumsy interface. |
Available features: Rear window and the wiper/washer more form over fnction. Inadequate for winter weather in northern climes. Wiper cycles before fluid sprayed on glass, wiper has single speed, cleans a very small area. No heated rear seats, rain sense wipers, power pedals |
| Top of page ^ |
Want to post your own reviews? Become a member--it's free for participants.
Want to view reviews for a different model? Then click:
Buick Enclave Forums (TrueDelta partners)
These forums have helped make our results possible. For discussions of the Enclave by owners, visit:
EnclaveForum.net -- Buick Enclave forum
GMInsideNews.com -- GM news forum
Direct links to this page
Regular link to this page:
http://www.truedelta.com/wntc.php?stage=pt&bd=Buick&mc=431
In BB Code, for forums:
[url=http://www.truedelta.com/wntc.php?stage=pt&bd=Buick&mc=431] Why (not) the Buick Enclave? (car buyer reviews)[/url]
About TrueDelta's "Why (Not) This Car?"
Hundreds of websites include Buick Enclave reviews. But with your typical Buick Enclave review car buyers must dig to find the information they really want. And too often they still don't find it.
With "Why (Not) This Car?" TrueDelta is providing the information many car buyers considering the Buick Enclave are looking for: the reasons to buy--or not buy--the Buick Enclave. As reported by other car buyers.
The survey process is simple:
- Select two cars to compare
- Describe your time in each
- Select reasons for buying one and not buying the other
- Explain and provide additional detail for these reasons

