Why (Not) the Ford Fusion?
Buyers' reasons for buying--or not buying--a particular car
View reviews for a different model
Direct link to this page
TrueDelta's "Why (Not) This Car?" reviews of the Ford Fusion, posted by owners, focus on the information most sought by many car buyers: the reasons to buy (or not buy) the Ford Fusion compared to other car models.
Not a member yet? Read about TrueDelta's research and how to participate by clicking here.
- Car buyer comparisons: Ford Fusion preferred
- Car buyer comparisons: Ford Fusion not preferred
- Single vehicle reviews: Ford Fusion pros and cons
Comparisons: Ford Fusion Preferred
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan | > | 2006 Mercury Milan4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Safety & braking: brakes work excellently and many safety features come standard |
Materials & workmanship: Whole overall interior quality |
Powertrain performance: smooth 3.0 V6 matched perfectly with 6spd auto |
Quietness: engine sound is quite muted even under high RPM's |
Handling: takes curves and corners quite well for a midsize family sedan |
| Top of page ^ |
| Mercury Milan: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Powertrain performance: 2.3 I4 5spd auto was rather sluggish and would be only considered adequate. NOT for someone that likes effortless acceleration, and likes low end power that a V6 offers. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan | > | 2006 Pontiac G64-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Safety & braking: front, side, and curtain air bags. stops on a dime. crash test ratings. |
Reliability & durability: feels solid, good reviews |
Available features: sync is awesome with hands free music and phone. ambiant lighting is fun. steering wheel controls. 17" wheels. Moon & Tune package with moonroof and 8 speaker audiophile sound system (better than any aftermarket I've heard). And did I mention sync? |
Materials & workmanship: all buttons feel solid. everything fits and flows. stains don't stick in carpet. |
Front seat comfort: I drive close to 2 hours a day and I stay comfortable all the time. tilt/telescoping steering wheel. adjustable lumbar support. seat isn't hard but not so soft that you want to fall asleep. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Pontiac G6: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Handling: quite simply, it was horrible. I drove 3 of these because I liked the exterior styling so much I wanted one to be better. but in all 3 I was able to jiggle the steering wheel back and forth without feeling it move the car. car drifted all over the road. |
Materials & workmanship: even in a car only 2 years old with less than 30,000 miles on it, all of the buttons on the dash were worn/wearing off. seats were stiff and uncomfortable |
Reliability & durability: I don't know about the reliability, but everything felt like cheap plastic that would break off in my hand. |
Front seat comfort: seat was stiff, didn't contour to my body. controls were inconveniently placed. |
| Top of page ^ |
2008 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan | > | 2008 Chevrolet Malibu4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Available features: Ford Sync is very useful "out of the box" and it will get free updates in the future which will add on even more features. Rear parking sensors are very convenient and make everything much easier for a klutz like me. |
Reliability & durability: It's got a rock-solid rep. 5/5 JD Power reliability rating, plenty of positive auto mag reviews, and Consumer Reports says that it's even more reliable than the Toyota Camry. |
Price or payments: You can typically find a good Fusion for less than a Malibu. I got a loaded '08 Fusion SE with ~7,000 miles priced at $14,499 for about $14k after trade-in (my beat-up '99 Cavalier), taxes, and fees. |
Exterior styling: Rather than looking ultra-conservative or outrageous and in your face, the Fusion's design strikes a balance between the two - it's bold but classy. The Sport Appearance Package really makes it look like a "guy's car". |
Handling: It handles like a race car! The ride is sporty without being rough. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Chevrolet Malibu: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Front seat comfort: I tried the LS cloth, LT2 Ultralux, and LTZ leather seats...all of them were uncomfortable. Too little padding. |
Rear seat room & comfort: Very uncomfortable; feels not unlike a park bench. There's no rear seat armrest and you don't have nearly as much leg room as in the Fusion. |
Interior styling: The hard plastic, scooped out back seats w/their "net" pockets look cheap. Actually, the whole back seat area is pretty uninviting. There's no overhead sunglasses compartment or rear seat armrest. |
Powertrain performance: 4-banger lacks power and seems to get consistently less than EPA ratings. The V6 engine is a beast but it has a widespread shuddering problem at ~1.5K RPM. |
| Top of page ^ |
2008 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan | > | 2004 Honda Civic4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Handling: The car handles confidently and capably, and feels much smaller on twisty roads than it actually is. |
Quietness: This is the quietest car I've ever owned. Cruising on the freeway, the interior is quiet enough to carry on a conversation without having to raise your voice. |
Ride smoothness: Even on pockmarked PA highways it takes a lot to upset this car. It rides nice and easy, but it's not too soft either. |
Front seat comfort: The power front seats are comfortable and there's plenty of room for even bigger-than-average folk like me to settle in. |
Rear seat room & comfort: Even with the driver's seat positioned for a 6-plus-footer, there's plenty of room in the back for a full-sized adult. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Honda Civic: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Price or payments: Buying a used Honda is a bad value proposition. Similar '04 and '05 Honda Civics all seemed to be going for over $10,000, and I wasn't about to pay that much for a 5 year old compact car. |
Powertrain performance: The Civic's engine was noisy and thrashy, and for all that racket it didn't seem to do much. Overall performance was lethargic despite the car's low curb weight. |
| Top of page ^ |
2007 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan | > | 2001 Ford Windstar4-door Minivan, ext. |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Clean styling that looks modern. |
Fuel economy: Good fuel economy for a sedan of that size. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Windstar: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Reliability & durability: Frequent break downs. Mostly electrical, HVAC, and transmission issues. |
Past personal experience: Hated the miserable piece of junk. Owned for 2 and a half years. Unless you want to be on a first name basis with your mechanic get a different van. |
| Top of page ^ |
Comparisons: Ford Fusion Not Preferred
2009 Toyota Prius4-door Hatch | > | 2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Toyota Prius: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Brand reputation & image: Toyota quality |
Discounts & incentives: Excellent pricing was offered on a new outgoing Gen. 2 fully loaded model. |
Audio & nav systems: They are excellent! |
Reliability & durability: Toyota's Prius has an excellent track record so I know it won't be in the shop on a regular basis |
Fuel economy: Averaging 42-45 mpg in first 45 days - |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Discounts & incentives: Dealer stuck to factory pricing |
Reliability & durability: This is a new car in hyrbid that has no track record |
Price or payments: At list price this car offered very little the Prius did not, at a much higher cost |
| Top of page ^ |
2010 Acura TSX4-door Sedan | > | 2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Acura TSX: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Powertrain performance: Very responsive engine and transmission. Transmission downshifts quickly when requested. |
Materials & workmanship: Feels very upscale, no gaps in trim, quality appears to be better thanthe Fusion. |
Handling: Very responsive, brakes are great! |
Driving position & visibility: Seats very comfortable, good visibility, seats keep driver in place. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Powertrain performance: Transmission reluctant to downshift, then downshifted too many gears, engine redlined but didn't feel very strong. Upshift then very abrupt and harsh. |
Materials & workmanship: Didn't feel very finished, some gaps in trim, plastic felt a little down scale. |
Past personal experience: Had a Ford in 2001. Car spent 53 days in shop, dealer finally replaced so many parts that they ultimately did get the correct part. Replacement part, alternator, failed after 3 months. Transmission also had to be replaced under warranty. |
Dealership practices: Played games regarding value of trade-in, then wouldn't give keys back when I tried to leave dealership. Very arrogant sales personnel. |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Ford Focus4-door Sedan | > | 2009 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Focus: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Handling: Very crisp and positive for a FWD sedan, especially one that sits so tall on its suspension. I have optional 17 inch wheel/tire package. |
Fuel economy: Quite acceptable around town, due to light weight. Very impressive on the highway, where I've seen 35-41 mpg depending on elevation and slope. |
Powertrain performance: Well-rounded two-liter engine with very responsive drive-by-wire throttle. Quiet at moderate revs and light throttle, with a little snarl when stood on. PZEV cleanliness. MTX-75 geared a bit short in first through third gears, good on hills and stop/go. |
Price or payments: $16,700 is quite a bit of money for a two-liter four sedan, but the Focus has build quality and content that justify it pretty well. |
Insurance & depreciation: Class-leading crash-worthiness test results yield affordable insurance rates andd some peace of mind. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Fuel economy: The non-hybrid four is pushing a lot of weight, so its city mileage suffers. |
Powertrain performance: Too little power for the weight of the vehicle (four cylinder, MTX-75). Sluggish acceleration from a stop. |
Price or payments: Payments would have been a bit over my budget for the four-cylinder; out-of-reach for the six (no manual, either, so no sale!) |
| Top of page ^ |
2007 Saturn AURA4-door Sedan | > | 2008 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Saturn AURA: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: The car has smooth lines with a hint of european styling. |
Ride smoothness: It was a softer and smoother ride than other cars in its class. |
Powertrain performance: The standard option 3.5L VVT V6 gave you pleanty of power for a base engine. The 4 speed tranny shifts as smooth as glass. |
Interior styling: The materials used and the overall styling was a step above other cars in its class. |
Discounts & incentives: I personally liked the 0% financing for 60 months. |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Interior styling: It looked a bit on the cheap side |
Powertrain performance: There was not enough get up and go with the 3.0L V6. |
Ride smoothness: It was a harder/stiffer ride than I perfer. |
Insurance & depreciation: I found out that insurance was a little more for this car than other cars in its class??? |
| Top of page ^ |
2009 Mazda Mazda64-door Sedan | > | 2008 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Mazda Mazda6: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Available features: Blind spot monitor, Bose stereo, bluetooth, push button start, Serius satelitte radio |
Exterior styling: Very sporty slippery design, very easy to wash. |
Control design: Very intuitive steering wheel controls that are easy to learn |
Front seat comfort: Infinate seat positions |
Ride smoothness: Handles most of the road bumps with very little jarring |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Interior styling: very undintiguished vs. other Ford interiors |
Available features: No Blind spot monitor but the SYNC system is fantastic-better than the Mazda's bluetooth |
Control design: The controls are layed out in such a way that you often have to take your eyes off the road to adjust the heat , stereo and criuse control |
Powertrain performance: It is a little dated (minor)-it's gas mileage is as good as my Mazda's but it strains more on an uphill grade |
| Top of page ^ |
Single Vehicle Reviews: Ford Fusion Pros and Cons
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Audio & nav systems: The Sony system in the Fusion Sport reminds me of a similar system in my Acura. Very accurate with good bass and sterling highs. The SYNC system is great in that it's free for the first three years and bluetooth phone and iPod integration is perfect. |
Interior styling: Nice materials and easy to use explains it all. Much better than the Honda or the Toyota. |
Materials & workmanship: Everything seems to be put together well and this is coming from a Toyota Camry and Acura TSX owner. The only gripe is color choices, but charcoal gray is better than not having any choices at all. |
Powertrain performance: Having owned many performance cars (including several Taurus SHO's, Mustang GT's, and others), I find this car superior in many aspects. It runs good and the new SelectShift transmission bests Chrysler and Acura slushboxes. |
Quietness: It is a quieter car than many larger vehicles. In fact, it seems quieter than the Toyota Camry we owned for some time. |
| Top of page ^ |
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: Front end restyling and back end restyling |
Interior styling: Quality of materials, fit and finish, available features |
Color choices: Good selection - love the tuxedo black |
Audio & nav systems: excellent nav system very complete. Sync is awesome! Sony stereo is great |
Materials & workmanship: fit and finish are excellent both inside and outside of car |
| Top of page ^ |
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: It is classic, very stylish and European in appearance. |
Powertrain performance: The Fusion is very responsive when power is needed for passing or hill climbing. |
Handling: The all-wheel drive instills a lot of confidence on challenging slippery roads. |
Cargo capacity & towing: I can load two golf bags and two suitcases with room to spare. |
Available features: All-wheel drive -every sedan should be available with all-wheel drive. The Sync system is also quite useful, although there are still some bugs to be ironed out. |
| Top of page ^ |
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Exterior styling: I think that its a very one of a kind car, that you can spot a mile away. The Fusion doesn't blend into a parking lot like a lot of other midsize cars. Its a great looking car. |
Interior styling: I love the black leather with contrast white stitching its a attractive feature. The gauges are awesome, they look great and are bright and easy to read. The blue back lighting to the switches is a great touch. Its has a great looking interior. |
Powertrain performance: I find the 3.0 Litre V6 to be a very quick and refined motor. Its powerful and its has a deep angry growl that I love. The 6 Spd select shift transmission is excellent, I love using the manual feature very handy. 240hp is more than enough power! |
Reliability & durability: I had a 2006 Ford Fusion SE V6 before my 2010 and it was an excellent car, and only got the 2010 because I fell in love with the looks of it. I put 65,000km on my 06 Fusion in 2 and a half years and no problems. It was a great and very reliable car. |
Past personal experience: I had a 06 Fusion SE V6 before my 2010 that I loved. It was a amazing car that I loved to wash and fuss over. I do the same thing with my 2010. I bought the '10 because I loved my 06 so much. I fully expect my '10 to be great car as well. |
| Top of page ^ |
2010 Ford Fusion4-door Sedan |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons to buy |
|---|
Powertrain performance: smooth, fun to drive |
Price or payments: cheaper than toyota or honda |
Quietness: very quiet ride |
Available features: Moonroof, sync, safety features |
Audio & nav systems: sync is great |
| Top of page ^ |
| Ford Fusion: Reasons not to buy |
|---|
Insurance & depreciation: does not hold resale value |
Brand reputation & image: worried about long term reliability |
| Top of page ^ |
Want to post your own reviews? Become a member--it's free for participants.
Want to view reviews for a different model? Then click:
Ford Fusion Forums (TrueDelta partners)
These forums have helped make our results possible. For discussions of the Fusion by owners, visit:
FordFusion.net -- Ford Fusion forum
Direct links to this page
Regular link to this page:
http://www.truedelta.com/wntc.php?stage=pt&bd=Ford&mc=98
In BB Code, for forums:
[url=http://www.truedelta.com/wntc.php?stage=pt&bd=Ford&mc=98] Why (not) the Ford Fusion? (car buyer reviews)[/url]
About TrueDelta's "Why (Not) This Car?"
Hundreds of websites include Ford Fusion reviews. But with your typical Ford Fusion review car buyers must dig to find the information they really want. And too often they still don't find it.
With "Why (Not) This Car?" TrueDelta is providing the information many car buyers considering the Ford Fusion are looking for: the reasons to buy--or not buy--the Ford Fusion. As reported by other car buyers.
The survey process is simple:
- Select two cars to compare
- Describe your time in each
- Select reasons for buying one and not buying the other
- Explain and provide additional detail for these reasons

