

Engine (40%)
Transmission and Drivetrain (7%)
Brakes and Traction Control (4%)
Suspension and Steering (13%)
Electrical and Air Conditioning (24%)
Paint, Rust, Leaks, Rattles, and Trim (7%)
Other (6%)
$2500+ (0%)
$1000 - $2499 (7%)
$500 - $999 (6%)
$100 - $499 (20%)
< $100 (67%)
6200 mi | Active Head Restraint on Passenger seat replaced due to excessive vibration and noise |
11780 mi | Pano Sunroof required replacement control unit and re-programming due to recurring fault 'rain closure not possible' that could not be resolved via programming / reset alone. |
turbocharged 300hp 3.0L I6 8-speed shiftable automatic RWD
42805 mi | Various clunks and rattles coming from interior rear during starts, stops, bumpy roads. |
turbocharged 255hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
69690 mi US $1000 |
The driver side, seat radar, door seal, passenger rear door seal. Broke letting go could not replace had to order new parts and replace. |
turbocharged 300hp 3.0L I6 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
34000 mi | Rattle from tailgate |
turbocharged 400hp 4.4L V8 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
45000 mi | Persistent rattle and creak at low speed over semi-rough terrain from rear hatch area. Repair attempted: replaced hatch auto-latch mechanism. Unsuccessful. Owner wrapped elec tape on D latch and tightened latch mechanism. Works so far.. |
turbocharged 300hp 3.0L I6 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
41000 mi | Glove box trim piece was warped and peeling away from the backing / door. Replaced under warranty. |
turbocharged 265hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
9000 mi | plastic protective housing which shields the electronics for power seat in the front right passenger seat keeps popping out. First time took it to dealer and they clipped it back in. Happened again. Objects on floor mat push to cause this. |
48200 mi | Also sun visor was broken and was replaced |
42160 mi | When the amplifier and head unit were replaced, the dealer damaged the air vent grill |
Engine not specified
36580 mi C $31 |
Hatch was making creaking noise. Problem still not fixed |
turbocharged 302hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
21700 mi | Controller aluminum trim had buckled. Controller needed to be replaced. |
turbocharged 300hp 3.0L I6 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
14000 mi | A creaky rear lift gate which the problem has reappeared and will be looked at again at next service. |
18200 mi | Rear lift gate creak. |
19900 mi | Rear lift gate repair previously not fixed correctly. Dealer service manager rode with me and diagnosed the issue. Lower rear portion of the lift gate was too tight and causing the upper gate to creak. Adjusted |
3300 mi | Lift gate making a hollow noise. Dealer put felt tape on the rear portion of the gate. Noise is not as noticeable but not gone. When I asked why car rattles at traffic stop, they said it was normal. Rental X5 made the same noises. |
Went in to rectify lift gate rattle and roll noise. Took 3 appointments so far. |
100120 mi US $300 |
Rear floor pan had standing water after snowfall. B-Pillar drains were cleaned and problem has not returned. |
42000 mi | bad rattle in rear iDrive screen badly scratched. Dealer attempted to clean, but didn't fix the issue |
turbocharged 265hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
9300 mi | Wind deflector for Sunroof repaired |
31820 mi | glove box door trim replaced |
51460 mi | Same bad design with the glovebox peeling back |
59520 mi | replacement of roof rails from painting peeling - under warranty bc of extended warranty |
43400 mi | Leak in drain valve from sunroof damaged computer for transmission. Had to order part from back east. |
11500 mi | Leak developed in the dome light near to the windshield. There is a TSB on the issue but we had to return a second time to get something replaced entirely. |
73000 mi | Front passenger door panel loose near door lock pin. |
27700 mi | On passenger seat, the leather seat would have a circular bulge on the side. This just make it look ugly. The dealer stated BMW warranty does not cover wear and tear item. |
26000 mi | problem with the telescoping steering wheel |
turbocharged 400hp 4.4L V8 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
57000 mi US $50 |
Drivers sun visor falls out of roof |
87700 mi US $180 |
Right front fender reflector came out after a car wash, bought adhesive tap and reinstalled |
97000 mi US $4 |
Side light on driver side, glued in place with silicon. |
turbocharged 300hp 3.0L I6 8-speed shiftable automatic AWD
9600 mi US $50 |
Sand abrasion on rocker panels; sanded and repainted |
6900 mi | Plastic covers for back seat hinges came off, dealer replaced plastic cover. Old cover had deformed clips so it couldn't hold on tight. |
turbocharged 265hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
44500 mi | Leather covering the side bolster on bottom of the driver's seat had ripped loose from the seat frame. Overnight stay required as part had to be shipped in from remote warehouse. |
47000 mi | Cover on vanity mirror in driver side sun visor slides freely causing the vanity light to come on unexpectedly during driving. |
49500 mi | Rattle and squeak in rear hatch when driving. |
16000 mi | Headlight washer covering was broken |
20000 mi | Hedlight washer cover broke for second time. Fixed on 1st trip. |
10540 mi | Black bumper trim on front bumper was misaligned. Dealer noted the clips holding the black bumper piece were not in and readjusted. |
17980 mi | Window seal on drivers door became loose and was replaced by the dealer. |
49000 mi | Rear hatch rattling. Adjusted |
10000 mi | Popping/creaking noise in left a/b pillar area when right front tire encountered raise in pavement. Happens occasionally. Techs reset all trim inside left door/window areas. No change. Reports on internet indicate it could be a cracked weld. Headliner, all left side door and window trim removed. Areas checked for broken welds. None found. Factory engineer applied "sound proofing sealer" around all areas to eliminate "oil can" distortion in unibody. |
13300 mi | Spot weld defect. Car made a small tick noise when turning or going over some bumps. They did the repair and for the most part the tick frequency definitely went down. Most people would not even hear it. |
turbocharged 265hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
60100 mi US $350 |
Turn signal came loose |
35300 mi | Driver's door had rattles that could not be isolated. Dealer cleaned and lubed doors seals, which appears to have fixed the rattle. |
42000 mi | Rattle in cargo area due to incorrectly adjusted bump stops for tailgate. |
24000 mi | Rear hatchaikovsky popping. |
6000 mi | Driver's side mirror developed a crack from the cold weather. BMW replaced under warranty. New mirror looks different than old, so obviously was a change in vendor or design due to common defect. |
3000 mi | Slight rattle from trunk latch. |
2000 mi | misaligned bumper cover |
27000 mi | Power hatch failure due to water leak |
8000 mi | Cruise Control stalk loose, makes clicking sound when toggling stalk. Entire switch unit replaced. |
10000 mi | Constant wind whistle on passenger side and rattling tailgate and/or moonroof. They could not replicate the rattles and said they did not have time to diagnose the wind noise, told to come back another time. |
16420 mi | Rattles from moonroof resulting from rain gutter coming into contact with moonroof glass. Buffer installed to eliminate noise. Persistent wind noise coming from passenger side outside mirror. Service bulletin found, repairs made. Persistent wind whistle from passenger outside mirror. Rattles from moonroof resulting from rain gutter coming into contact with moonroof glass. Buffer installed to eliminate noise. |
18720 mi | Drivers electric seat makes loud creaking noise when raised or lowered. |
30000 mi | Drivers electric seat made loud creaking noise when raised or lowered. |
260-horsepower 3.0L I6 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
9000 mi | tailgate rattles, fixed by adjusting latch. |
18000 mi | Tailgate would not close properly-Even when apparently close system would indicate it was open. Would rattle and de activated surround view of camera |
27000 mi | noise coming from tailgate, body rattle |
24607 mi | Fix left Rear Sunshade |
turbocharged 282hp 3.0L I6 Diesel 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
72000 mi | rattle from tailgate |
260-horsepower 3.0L I6 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
86000 mi US $200 |
sunroof wind deflector broke, had to install a new one |
34410 mi | 8 Trips to fix: - Tailgate rattles, seat rattling, strut mount failure, bumper moving.. thats right moving out of place, tailgate lock change, tailgate adjustment.. and rattles persist. I gave up. Cant wait till lease is up.. switch to merc |
350-horsepower 4.8L V8 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
111600 mi ¤1000 |
water leaks into the cabin during car wash. Water comes in from the panoramic roof. |
75020 mi C $2000 |
the track that the moon roof was on cracked and the moonroof would not close. |
138640 mi C $321 |
Replaced rear lights on door. they accumulate water from washing the vehicle and eventually fail. |
2480 mi | 1) rear boot trim rattles since day-1, unable to repair due to the flexing of the body shell 2) noise on front-right suspension, dealers could not reproduce problem, so not repaired, but problem still exists. Please dont buy a BMW X5 at least. |
3720 mi A $280 |
intermittent noises from front suspension, very hard to reproduce. |
8680 mi | Boot trunk rattles from plastic trims. Spent nearly 6hours to remove all trims, apply tapes and re-fit |
162000 mi US $400 |
Problem-class first noted 2016, during heavy rain, right-rear quarter-panel leaked, with electronic tailgate failure, replaced by dealer, who advised body shop replace moon-roof drains. In March, 2018, moon-roof drain plugged, left-rear quarter-panel flooded with strong rain or car-wash. Electronics (bluetooth cellphone function, USB, SOS) all failed. Independent shop cleared drain, with leakage resolved. Electronics repair postponed d/t cost. Also changed wiper blades, oil during this trip. |
33300 mi | Rattle behind the 2nd row latch (fixed) Rattle in the tailgate (not fixed) |
35000 mi | This time, they actually adjusted the rear hatch guides. It worked this time. Further, now that I know what to adjust, I can do so when the rattle comes back (comes back when weather changes from cold to hot, hot to cold). |
41000 mi | Center console wood trim cracked and steering wheel trim peeling = replaced Rear seat rattle = adjusted (again) |
50800 mi | Rear passenger seat creaks and rattles |
260-horsepower 3.0L I6 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
44000 mi US $350 |
leather on back of driver's seat separated and carpet anchor for driver's carpet mat was loose. |
47000 mi | Sunroof trim rattling |
90000 mi | Water ingress in rear lights in tailgate |
Engine not specified
24000 mi | Glove compartment door warped, preventing it from opening. Upper compartment door was replaced. Dealer had part in stock, so I waited under an hour for the complete repair. |
66000 mi US $1850 |
Sun roof drain channels clogged; caused short and replaced tailight and effected wiring harness and electrical components |
350-horsepower 4.8L V8 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
61380 mi C $150 |
Plastic piece off of the parking brake e-swith broke. Was replaced with a new switch. |
260-horsepower 3.0L I6 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
86180 mi C $500 |
Leaking rear doors were wetting rear floor |
30000 mi | Warped glove box leather panelling impeding opening of glove box |
110000 mi US $300 |
Water sipped into the back trunk near the storage compartment and down onto the electronic module near above the right wheel well causing the OBC to malfunction throwing multiple error codes while driving. |
315-horsepower 4.4L V8 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
88040 mi C $509 |
amplifier damaged by water (due to leaking sunroof drain) replacement amp purchased, still not installed |
225-horsepower 3.0L I6 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
67000 mi US $300 |
Driver's door was inoperable from outside. Ended up replacing several components in the door, cost was around $300. |
89000 mi US $50 |
Also replaced the worn out roundel emblem on the hood of the X5. It's not a big deal. |
355-horsepower 4.8L V8 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
50000 mi US $550 |
Had the windshield replaced. Leaking water from the overhead into the shifter and finally puddling on the drivers floor. Thought the sunroof was the issue. After removing the headliner the sun roof was ok. 4hr job. |
turbocharged 6-cylinder diesel automatic AWD
58280 mi | Door handle carrier broke. Pixel on MID dead |
315-horsepower 4.4L V8 6-speed shiftable automatic AWD
143300 mi US $350 |
Right front door handle |
225-horsepower 3.0L I6 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
71000 mi US $50 |
exterior trim around windows clouded, faded, and, in spots, anodization came off and revealed bare alum. estimate from dealer was $2300. painted myself instead. good immediate results, time will tell. this is a common problem with an X5 |
126000 mi US $300 |
Replaced rear windshield wiper nut cover. |
68200 mi C $1410 |
leaking sunroof, damaged elecrtrical module. fixed roof, dried floor and changed module |
102300 mi C $380 |
Leaking sunroof, onto floor. Drain plugs were unblocked and cleaned |
108800 mi C $700 |
roof leaking. cleaned, etc |
282-horsepower 4.4L V8 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
83080 mi | When sold, water leaking in through sunroof, |
225-horsepower 3.0L I6 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
120000 mi US $400 |
Replace rear wiper plastic cover, front wiper blades, plastic cover for the headlight washer, plastic insert for changes, oil and filter change, air filter replace with K&N filter. |
108000 mi US $1200 |
The factory HID headlight lenses were cloudy and could not be buffed out with standard restoration methods. Replace headlight assemblies. |
340-horsepower 4.6L V8 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
184240 mi C $650 |
Both front inner outside door handles broke. |
282-horsepower 4.4L V8 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
133000 mi US $108 |
Broke driver's door handle. |
225-horsepower 3.0L I6 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
112500 mi US $66 |
TAILGATE LATCH ADJUSTED TO REDUCE RATTLE IN TAILGATE |