BMW X1 BMW X1 2018 Porsche 911 Porsche 911 2017

We are 103,000+ car owners sharing real-world car information.

Join Us

BMW X1 vs. Porsche 911 Price Comparison (MSRP)

The sticker prices, before adjusting for remaining feature differences. Usually these are the numbers you will see on the window stickers.

Models in short supply often sell at or even above these prices.

BMW X1 vs. Porsche 911 Invoice Comparison

Lowest Total Price: $47,595

BMW X1 sDrive28i   
Difference: $60,480

Lowest Total Invoice: $44,885

BMW X1 sDrive28i   
Difference: $51,609

Calculate Payments

  Down Payment Interest Rate Term
Model Year2018201820172017201720172017
ModelX1X1911911911911911
TrimsDrive28ixDrive28iCarreraCarrera SCarrera GTSTurboTurbo S
Body4dr SUV4dr SUV2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe
Base Price $33,900 $35,900 $89,400 $103,400 $119,000 $159,200 $188,100
Base Invoice $32,205 $34,065 $80,460 $93,060 $107,100 $143,280 $169,290
Premium Tier 3,250 3,250          
M Sport Design 3,500 3,500          
Obstacle detection, rear 800 800          
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed 1,000 1,000 2,490 2,490 2,490 2,490 2,490
Driving Assistance Package 700 700          
Metallic paint (extra cost) 550 550 710 710 710    
Leather seating surfaces 1,450 1,450          
Apple CarPlay support 300 300          
Panoramic sunroof 1,150 1,150          
Heated steering wheel     470 470   0 0
Premium Package Plus     3,970 3,970 4,570    
Adaptive sport seats plus     3,825 3,825   1,145  
Roof rack     400 400 400 400 400
Sunroof     1,990 1,990 1,990   1,990
Wood trim     1,770 1,770   1,990 0
Rear wiper     360 360 360 360 360
Power-folding mirrors     320 320 0 320 0
Torque vectoring, brake-based     1,320        
LED headlights         2,765    
Carbon fiber / leather-wrapped steering wheel         470    
Interior ambient lighting           510 510
Proximity key           1,090 1,090
Auto-dimming headlights           500  
Premium Tier 2,990 2,990          
M Sport Design 3,220 3,220          
Obstacle detection, rear 735 735          
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed 920 920 2,117 2,117 2,117 2,117 2,117
Driving Assistance Package 645 645          
Metallic paint (extra cost) 505 505 604 604 604    
Leather seating surfaces 1,335 1,335          
Apple CarPlay support 275 275          
Panoramic sunroof 1,060 1,060          
Heated steering wheel     400 400   0 0
Premium Package Plus     3,375 3,375 3,884    
Adaptive sport seats plus     3,251 3,251   973  
Roof rack     340 340 340 340 340
Sunroof     1,692 1,692 1,692   1,692
Wood trim     1,505 1,505   1,692 0
Rear wiper     306 306 306 306 306
Power-folding mirrors     272 272 0 272 0
Torque vectoring, brake-based     1,122        
LED headlights         2,350    
Carbon fiber / leather-wrapped steering wheel         400    
Interior ambient lighting           434 434
Proximity key           927 927
Auto-dimming headlights           425  
Options (change) 12,700 12,700 17,625 16,305 13,755 8,805 6,840
Options (change) 11,685 11,685 14,984 13,862 11,693 7,486 5,816
Destination 995 995 1,050 1,050 1,050 1,050 1,050
Total Price $47,595 $49,595 $108,075 $120,755 $133,805 $169,055 $195,990
Total Invoice $44,885 $46,745 $96,494 $107,972 $119,843 $151,816 $176,156

Return to top

While we strive for accuracy, the site is not error-free, and prices can change at any time.

Dealer Price Quotes

Want to find out how much dealers are willing to discount these cars?

Request free, no-obligation BMW X1 dealer quotes or Porsche 911 dealer quotes from dealers using our car quote form.

The process is easy and takes just a minute or two. You'll receive price quotes from local approved dealers within 48 hours.

TrueDelta Value Comparison: BMW X1 vs. Porsche 911

Lowest Adjusted Price and Invoice: BMW X1 sDrive28i
TrueDelta Adjusted Price Difference: $62,040
TrueDelta Adjusted Invoice Difference: $53,080
Model Year2018201820172017201720172017
ModelX1X1911911911911911
TrimsDrive28ixDrive28iCarreraCarrera SCarrera GTSTurboTurbo S
Body4dr SUV4dr SUV2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe
Engine228hp I4228hp I4370hp H6420hp H6450hp H6540hp H6580hp H6
TransmissionT8T8M7M7M7S7S7
DrivetrainFWDAWDRWDRWDRWDAWDAWD
EPA Fuel Economy (city/highway)/ MPG/ MPG/ MPG/ MPG/ MPG/ MPG/ MPG
Audio (watts, speakers)205, 7205, 7?, 8?, 8?, 8555, 12555, 12
Tire (rear if not all the same)225/50-18225/50-18235/40-19245/35-20245/35-20245/35-20245/35-20
Total Price$47,595$49,595$108,075$120,755$133,805$169,055$195,990
Adjustments for Features-1,560-3,26000-1,200-6,700-11,200
Feature-Adjusted Total Price$46,035$46,335$108,075$120,755$132,605$162,355$184,790
Cost Above Minimum$0$300$0$12,680$24,530$54,280$76,715
Total Invoice$44,885$46,745$96,494$107,972$119,843$151,816$176,156
Adjustments for Features-1,471-3,07300-1,075-6,017-10,067
Feature-Adjusted Total Invoice$43,414$43,672$96,494$107,972$118,768$145,799$166,089
Cost Above Minimum$0$258$0$11,478$22,274$49,305$69,595

Return to top

Features Comparison: BMW X1 vs. Porsche 911

Model Year2018201820172017201720172017
ModelX1X1911911911911911
TrimsDrive28ixDrive28iCarreraCarrera SCarrera GTSTurboTurbo S
Body4dr SUV4dr SUV2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe2dr Coupe
Transmission and Drivetrain 
8-speed manually-shiftable automatic$1300$1300     
7-speed manual  $300$300$300  
7-speed automated manual     $1200$1200
FWD$0      
AWD $1700   $1700$1700
RWD  $0$0$0  
Accessories 
Hands-free trunk or liftgate$100$100     
Heated steering wheel  $100$100$100$100$100
Power liftgate$350$350     
Power rear side windows$200$200     
Semi-automated parking system$500$500     
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, manual$250$250     
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power  $350$350$350$350$350
Brakes, Airbags, and Other Safety 
Automatic braking, low-speed$200$200     
Ceramic brake rotors      $4000
Hill descent control$250$250     
Lane departure warning$200$200     
Pedestrian detection$50$50     
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system  $0$0$0$0$0
Rollover sensor$50$50     
Secondary collision brake assist  $25$25$25$25$25
Tires, run-flat$150$150     
Cargo Management 
Cargo cover$75$75     
Roof rack  $300$300$300$300$300
Roof rails$250$250     
Storage compartment under front seat(s)$50$50     
Trailering equipment (4 wire)$125$125     
Climate Control 
Rear air vents$100$100     
Residual heat  $50$50$50$50$50
Water-repellent front-door glass  $15$15$15$15$15
Drivetrain 
Electronically-variable engine mounts (performance-oriented)    $500$500$500
Limited-slip rear differential  $300$300$300$300$300
Engine / Motor 
Dual-mode exhaust, switchable    $500  
Rear-engine configuration  $0$0$0$0$0
Exterior 
Active front spoiler     $500$500
Active grille shutters  $0$0$0$0$0
Active rear spoiler  $300$300$300$300$300
Black exterior trim (optional)$0$0  $0  
Body kit (gray/black)    $0$0$0
Bodyside cladding$350$350     
Deep-tinted rear windows$275$275     
Painted brake calipers (optional)   $0$0$0$0
Panoramic sunroof$1200$1200     
Rear spoiler$200$200     
Retractable rear spoiler  $400$400$400  
Sunroof  $900$900$900$900$900
Tall rear wing-type spoiler     $500$500
Wheel-lip moldings$75$75     
Infotainment 
DVD-Audio-compatible player  $0$0$0$0$0
DVD-compatible player$0$0     
Off-road navigation system  $0$0$0$0$0
S Voice support$0$0     
Satellite radio  $200$200$200$200$200
Satellite radio - one year subscription$250$250     
SD Card slot  $25$25$25$25$25
Surround sound     $250$250
Traffic + travel information$25$25     
Traffic information  $25$25$25$25$25
Voice control for external devices$0$0     
Wi-Fi hotspot  $50$50$50$50$50
Instruments, Lights, and Mirrors 
Auto-dimming passenger-side mirror  $75$75$75$75$75
Boost gauge  $75$75$75$75$75
Chronometer    $100$100$100
Compass$0$0     
Fog light, rear  $100$100$100$100$100
Fog lights$125$125     
Head-up display (HUD)$350$350     
Headlight washers  $50$50$50$50$50
LED headlights  $1000$1000$1000$1000$1000
LED headlights, single projector or low beam only$750$750     
Mirror tilt-down in reverse$25$25     
Performance data recording app    $200  
Performance meter    $150$150$150
Steering-linked headlights  $150$150$150$150$150
Turn signals on or near mirrors$25$25     
Seats and Interior Trim 
Aluminum trim    $100  
Carbon fiber / leather-wrapped steering wheel    $150  
Center armrest(s), second row$50$50     
Cooled or ventilated front seats  $300$300   
Folding second row seats$300$300     
Folding second row seats w/o opening to trunk  $75$75$75$75$75
Leather door panel trim  $250$250 $250$250
Leather-wrapped steering wheel$150$150$150$150 $150$150
Manual thigh support length adjuster, driver seat$50$50     
Manual thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat$50$50     
Metal pedals  $75$75$75$75$75
Power thigh bolsters, driver seat  $100$100$100$100$100
Power thigh bolsters, passenger seat  $100$100$100$100$100
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat  $100$100$100$100$100
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat  $100$100$100$100$100
Synthetic suede door panel trim    $250  
Synthetic suede headliner  $650$650$650$650$650
Synthetic suede inserts in leather seating surfaces    $0  
Upholstered instrument panel, leather     $1000$1000
Wood trim$300$300$300$300 $300$300
Suspension, Wheels, and Tires 
Active stabilizer bars      $500
Adaptive dampers - electrical  $500$500$500$500$500
Alloy wheels$350$350$350$350$350 $350
Electronic systems calibration selector$200$200  $200$200$200
Polished alloy wheels     $350 
Rear wheel steering     $1500$1500
Transmission 
Downshift rev matching    $50  
Steering-wheel-mounted transmission controls$100$100   $100$100
Total Value of Features$9,400$11,100$7,840$7,840$9,040$14,540$19,040
Value of Feature Adjustments$1,560$3,260$0$0$1,200$6,700$11,200
Value of Feature Adjustments-1,471-3,07300-1,075-6,017-10,067

Return to top

Specifications Comparison: BMW X1 vs. Porsche 911

Model Year20182017
ModelX1911
Body4dr SUV2dr Coupe
Wheelbase105.1 in96.5 in
Length174.8 in177.1 in
Width71.7 in71.2 in
Height63.5 in50.9 in
Curb Weight3,544 lb.3,154 lb.
Fuel Capacity16.1 gal.16.9 gal.
Row 1 Headroom42.0 in0.0 in
Row 1 Shoulder Room56.7 in0.0 in
Row 1 Legroom40.4 in0.0 in
Row 2 Headroom39.4 in0.0 in
Row 2 Shoulder Room57.2 in0.0 in
Row 2 Legroom37.0 in0.0 in
Cargo Volume,
Minimum
27.1 ft35.1 ft3
Cargo Volume,
Maximum
58.7 ft314.3 ft3

Return to top

Option Package Details
BMW X1 sDrive28i

Premium Tier
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated front seats200Yes
Heated steering wheel100No
Head-up display (HUD)350No
Cornering lights50Yes
Hands-free trunk or liftgate100No
LED headlights, single projector or low beam only750Yes
S Voice support0No
4G LTE connectivity0Yes
Navigation map updates, three years0Yes
DVD-compatible player0No
Voice control for nav and audio100Yes
Media drive15Yes
In-vehicle Internet150Yes
Handwriting recognition200Yes
Siri Eyes Free support0Yes
Navigation system600Yes
Traffic + travel information25No
Remote app25Yes
Total Requested209078%
Total Not Requested57522%
M Sport Design
FeatureValueRequested?
Wood trim300Yes
Bodyside cladding100No
Special interior trim0No
Sport front fascia (optional)0No
Sport rear fascia, e.g. diffuser (optional)0No
Steering-wheel-mounted transmission controls100Yes
Black exterior trim (optional)0No
Manual thigh support length adjuster, driver seat50Yes
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Manual thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat50Yes
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Front sport buckets100Yes
Proximity key250Yes
Power-folding mirrors50Yes
Perimeter approach lighting25No
Satellite radio - one year subscription250No
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Universal garage door opener100Yes
Auto-dimming rearview mirror150Yes
Auto-dimming driver-side mirror75Yes
Compass0No
Total Requested172582%
Total Not Requested37518%
Driving Assistance Package
FeatureValueRequested?
Auto-dimming headlights200Yes
Speed limit information0No
Lane departure warning200No
Automatic braking, low-speed200No
Forward collision warning200Yes
Pedestrian detection50No
Total Requested40047%
Total Not Requested45053%

Option Package Details
BMW X1 xDrive28i

Premium Tier
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated front seats200Yes
Heated steering wheel100No
Head-up display (HUD)350No
Cornering lights50Yes
Hands-free trunk or liftgate100No
LED headlights, single projector or low beam only750Yes
S Voice support0No
4G LTE connectivity0Yes
Navigation map updates, three years0Yes
DVD-compatible player0No
Voice control for nav and audio100Yes
Media drive15Yes
In-vehicle Internet150Yes
Handwriting recognition200Yes
Siri Eyes Free support0Yes
Navigation system600Yes
Traffic + travel information25No
Remote app25Yes
Total Requested209078%
Total Not Requested57522%
M Sport Design
FeatureValueRequested?
Wood trim300Yes
Bodyside cladding100No
Special interior trim0No
Sport front fascia (optional)0No
Sport rear fascia, e.g. diffuser (optional)0No
Steering-wheel-mounted transmission controls100Yes
Black exterior trim (optional)0No
Manual thigh support length adjuster, driver seat50Yes
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Manual thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat50Yes
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Front sport buckets100Yes
Proximity key250Yes
Power-folding mirrors50Yes
Perimeter approach lighting25No
Satellite radio - one year subscription250No
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Universal garage door opener100Yes
Auto-dimming rearview mirror150Yes
Auto-dimming driver-side mirror75Yes
Compass0No
Total Requested172582%
Total Not Requested37518%
Driving Assistance Package
FeatureValueRequested?
Auto-dimming headlights200Yes
Speed limit information0No
Lane departure warning200No
Automatic braking, low-speed200No
Forward collision warning200Yes
Pedestrian detection50No
Total Requested40047%
Total Not Requested45053%

Option Package Details
Porsche 911 Carrera

Adaptive cruise control, all-speed
FeatureValueRequested?
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed700Yes
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system0No
Automatic braking, high-speed or partial200Yes
Forward collision warning200Yes
Total Requested1100100%
Total Not Requested00%
Heated steering wheel
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated steering wheel100No
Audio controls on steering wheel125Yes
Total Requested12556%
Total Not Requested10044%
Torque vectoring, brake-based
FeatureValueRequested?
Torque vectoring, brake-based100Yes
Limited-slip rear differential300No
Total Requested10025%
Total Not Requested30075%
Premium Package Plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Cooled or ventilated front seats300No
Auto-dimming headlights200Yes
Proximity key250Yes
Interior ambient lighting150Yes
LED headlights500No
Heated front seats200Yes
Steering-linked headlights150No
Headlight washers50No
Cornering lights50Yes
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power tilt adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat100No
Memory system, driver seat200Yes
Power tilt adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Auto-dimming rearview mirror150Yes
Auto-dimming driver-side mirror75Yes
Auto-dimming passenger-side mirror75No
Total Requested197559%
Total Not Requested137541%
Adaptive sport seats plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Power thigh bolsters, driver seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Power thigh bolsters, passenger seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Front sport buckets100Yes
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power tilt adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat100No
Memory system, driver seat200Yes
Power tilt adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Total Requested120071%
Total Not Requested50029%

Option Package Details
Porsche 911 Carrera S

Adaptive cruise control, all-speed
FeatureValueRequested?
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed700Yes
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system0No
Automatic braking, high-speed or partial200Yes
Forward collision warning200Yes
Total Requested1100100%
Total Not Requested00%
Heated steering wheel
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated steering wheel100No
Audio controls on steering wheel125Yes
Total Requested12556%
Total Not Requested10044%
Premium Package Plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Cooled or ventilated front seats300No
Auto-dimming headlights200Yes
Proximity key250Yes
Interior ambient lighting150Yes
LED headlights500No
Heated front seats200Yes
Steering-linked headlights150No
Headlight washers50No
Cornering lights50Yes
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power tilt adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat100No
Memory system, driver seat200Yes
Power tilt adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Auto-dimming rearview mirror150Yes
Auto-dimming driver-side mirror75Yes
Auto-dimming passenger-side mirror75No
Total Requested197559%
Total Not Requested137541%
Adaptive sport seats plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Power thigh bolsters, driver seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Power thigh bolsters, passenger seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Front sport buckets100Yes
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power tilt adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat100No
Memory system, driver seat200Yes
Power tilt adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Total Requested120071%
Total Not Requested50029%

Option Package Details
Porsche 911 Carrera GTS

LED headlights
FeatureValueRequested?
LED headlights500No
Auto-dimming headlights200Yes
Total Requested20029%
Total Not Requested50071%
Carbon fiber / leather-wrapped steering wheel
FeatureValueRequested?
Carbon fiber / leather-wrapped steering wheel0No
Audio controls on steering wheel125Yes
Heated steering wheel100No
Total Requested12556%
Total Not Requested10044%
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed
FeatureValueRequested?
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed700Yes
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system0No
Automatic braking, high-speed or partial200Yes
Forward collision warning200Yes
Total Requested1100100%
Total Not Requested00%
Premium Package Plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Proximity key250Yes
Interior ambient lighting150Yes
Heated front seats200Yes
Power thigh bolsters, driver seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Power thigh bolsters, passenger seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Tilt/telescoping steering wheel, power100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power tilt adjuster, driver seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, driver seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, driver seat100No
Power fore-aft adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Power 4-way lumbar adjuster, passenger seat150Yes
Power thigh support length adjuster, passenger seat100No
Memory system, driver seat200Yes
Power tilt adjuster, passenger seat100Yes
Auto-dimming rearview mirror150Yes
Auto-dimming driver-side mirror75Yes
Auto-dimming passenger-side mirror75No
Total Requested192577%
Total Not Requested57523%

Option Package Details
Porsche 911 Turbo

Heated steering wheel
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated steering wheel100No
Audio controls on steering wheel125Yes
Total Requested12556%
Total Not Requested10044%
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed
FeatureValueRequested?
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed700Yes
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system0No
Automatic braking, high-speed or partial200Yes
Forward collision warning200Yes
Total Requested1100100%
Total Not Requested00%
Adaptive sport seats plus
FeatureValueRequested?
Power thigh bolsters, driver seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, driver seat100Yes
Power thigh bolsters, passenger seat100No
Power seatback bolsters, passenger seat100Yes
Front sport buckets100Yes
Total Requested30060%
Total Not Requested20040%

Option Package Details
Porsche 911 Turbo S

Heated steering wheel
FeatureValueRequested?
Heated steering wheel100No
Audio controls on steering wheel125Yes
Total Requested12556%
Total Not Requested10044%
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed
FeatureValueRequested?
Adaptive cruise control, all-speed700Yes
Radar- or camera-based collision preparation system0No
Automatic braking, high-speed or partial200Yes
Forward collision warning200Yes
Total Requested1100100%
Total Not Requested00%

Was this information useful?

We're glad we could help! Share this page:

We're so sorry! Tell us how we can improve it.

See TrueDelta's information for all SUVs
See TrueDelta's information for all BMW models.