We are 108,000+ car owners sharing real-world car information.

Join Us

2002 Mazda Protege Pros and Cons at TrueDelta: Owning this car is an exercise in need vs. want. by ijbrekke

ijbrekke

0

Sign in or join to like this review.

Introduction

I've now owned my P5 for 4 years and driven about 55,000 miles. Owning this car has been a mostly positive experience with a number of drawbacks, most of them being the slow discovery of the faults of this car. I continue to own it because A) the positives continue to outweigh the negatives, and B) I have yet to find a newer car that I like better, is affordable, and is reliable.

If I were to sum up how I feel about my P5: I desperately want to love this car, but am forced to just like it because it has never quite been the car I think it should have been. It's the perfect size with the perfect steering feel, economy, and cost of maintenance/reliability. It desperately needs much more sound deadening, about 20-30 more horsepower, and a sixth gear for highway cruising (70 mph is about 3300 rpm). With these simple additions it could have been a much, much better car overall.

Would I buy it again? Probably, though I would seriously shop other hatchbacks/small wagons to see if I could avoid some of the things that bother me about this car. If you are less sensitive to its faults than I am you will absolutely love it. For me, I just like it, and that's been enough to not replace it yet.

Reviewed: 2002 Mazda Protege5

4dr Wagon 130-horsepower 2.0L I4 5-speed manual FWD

Why the 2002 Mazda Protege5?

Exterior styling

Great looking car, even at 12 years old (currently).

Fuel economy

I average right around 30mpg with mixed driving, a little highway-biased. I've been satisfied with the overall gas mileage.

Handling

Handles EXTREMELY well for a front-drive economy car, excellent steering feel and feedback. Every time I go to test drive new cars I am disappointed because I am used to the Protege5. I have yet to drive a new car that can match the steering feel of this car.

Driving position & visibility

Very easy to see out of, unlike many newer cars. The position feels a little high at first but becomes an advantage after adjusting because of the increased visibility offered.

Reliability & durability

My car has needed repairs in the time I've had it, but nothing that a normal 10+ year old car wouldn't routinely need. It has never stranded me or had a part fail that I wasn't expecting.

Why Not the 2002 Mazda Protege5?

Quietness

This is a LOUD car. I've taken some of the interior apart and there is basically zero sound-deadening material installed from the factory. Nearly everyone that rides in the car comments on how much road and engine noise there is. Not a great car for extended highway trips.

Ride smoothness

This has a shorter wheelbase and a semi-firm suspension, so things can get bumpy. This is directly linked to the great handling qualities listed in the pros: you're simply not going to have the best of both worlds in an economy car of this age.

Powertrain performance

Don't buy this car if you're looking for a great engine. It's adequate at best, and as it's aged it has developed a fair amount of vibration felt throughout the cabin. I would say that the engine is the worst large component on the car overall, something that Mazda addressed with the Mazda3 that replaced this car.

Materials & workmanship

This is a cheap car with a cheap interior. But I do like that it doesn't try to be something it's not: nothing in the interior feels gimmicky or fabricated. It's just cheap and plain, nothing luxurious about it.

Return to top

Sign in or join TrueDelta to post your own thoughts.

Return to top

See TrueDelta's information for all Mazda models.

Thanks for your interest in TrueDelta!