The Hyundai Santa Fe is pretty good, but the new 2016 Kia Sorento handles and rides better, and I also personally prefer its styling. But if you want slightly new rather than used, it'll be too new. I'll be writing this one up in the next few weeks.
The new Forester has been very reliable so far, but past Subarus can get iffy once over 100k mles. So it depends on how long you'll have it.
I also like the Mazda CX-5. For my full impressions, check the review linked below the photo.