I suspect no one has responded for a couple of reasons:
1. You place a high priority on reliability, but none of the cars you liked owning is known for reliability. If those were reliable enough for you, then just about anything newish should be okay.
2. Other than reliability, it's unclear what you like and dislike about a car, or what sort of vehicle you'd prefer. Sedan / wagon / SUV covers nearly everything.
Which cars are you considering, and what do you like and dislike about them?