Bad Mistress

Manual or automatic transmission?

Any further quidance on what sort of car appeals to you?

My initial thoughts are a Honda Civic Si (or if you want something more adult or more luxurious or need an automatic) an Acura TSX. The 2004-2008 TSX is more fun to drive than the 2009-2014, but they're also getting up in age.

An Infiniti G37 is another possibility if you want more power.

Any reactions to these suggestions?

Buick Verano or a Buick Encore if you want AWD. The Verano is the quietest and smoothest sub compact available with 2.0T 260 horsepower and 6-speed manual transmission. Or if you need ulitiy the Ecore with AWD handles as good as a Mazda and get 40 mpg.

Also for ultimate handling and luxury in a small package is the Cadillac ATS 2.0T.