Both are fine, simple cars. Subaru Impreza is another good choice if you want AWD. Some do burn oil but as long as you maintain the oil level will last as long as the Toyota and Honda mentioned.
Another reliable car very close in reliablity is the Chevy Aveo. It is a solid car from GM Korea that is in the class of the cars you mentioned.
Would recommend you test used options in your area and pick from the two you mentioned as well as the two others I mention. Some on this board hate GM and others love them. I am in the middle - they have some good cars in some classes, and in others I avoid them as much as I can. In this class they are fine.