First, the 2008-2013 Highlander is a comfy, but not exciting SUV. It can be had with a 3rd row and gets much better MPG than a Suburban, especially when you can get it as a hybrid (but that might go over your budget). The Highlander is really reliable and comes with a quick, smooth V6 engine (the hybrid is faster than the V6 and gets more MPG, but more $$$$$).
Second, the 2008 Honda Pilot is a roomy, mostly comfortable SUV with OK MPG and is reliable.
1 |

